On August 15, the Associated Press blasted a headline: “Florida Department of Health identifies Keely Farms Dairy as the source of raw milk that sickened 21 people.” Millions read it. No causation had been proven. The farm wasn’t even contacted before the announcement.
Days later, FOX35 Orlando piled on with a lawsuit claim: a woman blamed Keely Farms’ milk for her miscarriage. The emotional framing was obvious — splash a hospital photo across the screen, and guilt is cemented before trial.
But here’s what AP and FOX didn’t tell you: Keely Farms’ own independent lab results came back clean. On August 15, CentralStar Cooperative reported that all three tanks tested negative for E. coli. “Undetected. Final Result: Negative.”
The science said safe. The headlines said guilty. Welcome to the smear machine.
The Playbook in Real Time
- Announce first, test later. Florida DOH named Keely Farms before evidence existed.
- Media echo chamber. AP → FOX → social media panic.
- Insert lawsuits. Civil suits keep the narrative alive regardless of lab proof.
- Ignore receipts. Independent testing is sidelined.
This is the same playbook used against other dairies:
- In 2006, Organic Pastures was quarantined after a cluster of illnesses, yet all tested products came back negative for E. coli O157:H7.
- In 2011, CDFA issued a statewide recall of Organic Pastures products with no positive test results linking the dairy to contamination.
- In 2023, Raw Farm LLC (formerly Organic Pastures) faced a consent decree after 15 years of federal litigation. Later that year, lawsuits tied to a Salmonella outbreak ensured the smear narrative stuck.
- And decades earlier, Alta Dena Dairy, once the largest raw milk supplier in the U.S., was hammered by regulatory and legal actions, including a 1985 lawsuit accusing it of false advertising — part of a long campaign that ended with Alta Dena folded into Dean Foods.
Follow the Money
This isn’t random. It’s cartel math.
- Land O’Lakes spent $2.49 million lobbying in 2024.
- The National Milk Producers Federation spent $1.8 million.
- The International Dairy Foods Association added another $1 million.
According to OpenSecrets industry data, that’s over $5 million in dairy lobbying in 2024 alone — nearly all focused on “safety standards,” school lunch contracts, and subsidies that benefit pasteurized milk.
Meanwhile, DFA’s PAC poured $600,314 into the 2024 election cycle, mostly to Republican incumbents who keep industrial milk protections in place.
The result: pasteurization mandates locked in since 1987, FDA bans on interstate raw milk sales, and a ready-made legal weapon to smear independents the moment consumer demand grows.
The Timing Isn’t Coincidence
This latest Florida hit didn’t come out of nowhere. Just weeks ago, North Dakota passed HB 1131, expanding raw milk product sales and signaling a wave of food freedom momentum. Consumer demand is surging. Legislatures are moving.
And right on cue — Florida delivers the perfect national scare story.
Who Wins, Who Loses
- Winners: The cartel — DFA, Land O’Lakes, IDFA, and the regulatory allies who enforce their market moat. They keep school contracts, subsidies, and control of distribution.
- Losers: Independent dairies like Keely, who can have their name dragged through the mud even when their tanks test clean. Consumers, who lose access to nutrient-dense alternatives. Families, who watch local food destroyed while being herded into plastic jugs from conglomerates.
The Verdict
This isn’t food safety. If it were, regulators would demand causation proof before recall announcements. This is food control.
Big Dairy’s lobbying machine ensures every smear lands like a financial kill shot. From Alta Dena to Organic Pastures to Keely, the pattern is identical: smear, squeeze, consolidate.
The tanks were clean. The smear was dirty.
Stand with Keely Farms — donate to their defense and survival fund here.
Support real local food freedom — find and buy direct from ranchers at BeefMaps.com.
0 Comments